This article originally appeared in the Santa Barbara Independent online on March 29, 2008. To see the PDF of the article, click here.
Miserly Child Marvels at Savings Previously Spent on Soda
By Kevin Bourke
Saturday, March 29, 2008
Dear Kevin,
We’re concerned about raising financially responsible kids, but don’t know how far to take
it. Any thoughts on strategy?
Is there anything more important to parents than their children? We all want the best for our kids.
This issue of children and money is dear to me, since I have two daughters, ages 10 and 13. As a
financial planner, I’m always looking for ways to teach my children the value of money.
Recently, I was playing the board game called Life with my daughter Rachael, and it struck me that
there are some good lessons to be learned there. In the board game, a player can purchase a card
with the word “stock’ and a number between one and ten printed on it. The card costs $50,000, and
the player receives $10,000 each time the spinner lands on the number printed on the card.
Lesson One: Invest early. The earlier a player buys ‘stock’, the more chances there are for the
spinner to land on their number. When the spinner lands on their number 5 times, they have
received their investment back, and any time the spinner lands on their number after that is
pure profit. So, invest early in the game for a better chance at coming out ahead.
Lesson Two: Spend less than you earn. When it comes time to buy a house, each player is offered
two choices of homes. The prettier the house, the more expensive the house. When it comes time
to purchase a home, which one do you suppose a child picks? Yes, the prettier, more expensive
home, leaving them less money to buy ‘stock’. Another opportunity to teach a basic money lesson.
Of course, I wanted to teach a lesson with every spin of the wheel – my daughter just wanted to
play the game. Eventually I had to set aside my teaching hat and just enjoy playing the game of
‘Life’ with my daughter. The board game Life is not the only way, or even the best way, to teach
money lessons, but it is simple and fun.
In our family, we started offering cash to our girls in place of sodas at restaurants (for the record,
we don’t keep soda in the house). For example, if they chose to skip a soda at the restaurant, we
would credit them with that amount of cash, and pay them a lump sum at the end of the month. We
have been surprised with the great results we’ve seen with this simple practice. For one thing, our
kids drink less soda, which is a good thing. After two months of this practice, our younger daughter
received over $22 in cash at the end of the month from her ‘soda’ account. One day she said, “I
can’t believe how much we used to spend on soda.”
Lesson learned. Score one for the parents.
Allowances are another thing to consider. Some believe allowances help children learn about
money, some feel they do the opposite. For our family, allowances have been an opportunity for
the children to learn simple budgeting. While they are not expected to pay for necessities out of
their allowance, they are expected to pay for the occasional movie, game, toy, or even a clothing
item. It does not take long before the kids learn that they cannot buy everything they see. In fact,
my observation has been that when the kids are in charge of their own finances, they turn
downright miserly.
What about when they ask for extra money, or for a raise? Our first inclination might be to dismiss
this as whining. But, if we as parents are calm and approach this as a teaching opportunity, we can
help them learn negotiating skills which may serve them later in life. Some day they may need to
ask their boss for a raise. Wouldn’t it be nice if they had some experience with the process?
If a child asks their parent, “What do I need to do to get an extra $10 per month?” won’t the
parent appreciate their serious mature approach? So will an employer. Or if the child does extra
work around the house to earn money for a specific goal, doesn’t everybody feel better about it? So
rather than viewing their request as a sign of immaturity, why not view it as an initiative?
We also practice matching their savings for a specific item, similar to when an employer matches
contributions to a 401(k). When the children want something big, we agree on a matching ratio,
and they start saving. We might even offer to give them $2 for every dollar they save. This seems
to work well.
Finally, and maybe most importantly, kids imitate what their parents do, for better or worse. Why
not discuss your own savings discipline with your children? Better yet, teach by example.
Now if the board game Life just offered a 401(k)…
